0 items in cart

FREE SHIPPING EVERY DAY Order within 3 hours and 46 minutes to ship today

Page Content Begins Here
Sort Results
FILTERS (2) 30 FOUND Reset Done
Coming Soon
Glove Coach TRY OUR GLOVE COACH Answer a few simple questions to find your perfect glove.

Extra Stiff at least 4 stars

30 FOUND

Extra Stiff at least 4 stars CLEAR ALL
Popular Popular, click to sort ascending Latest Latest, click to sort descending Avg. Rating Avg. Rating, click to sort descending Savings Savings, click to sort descending $: Low to High $: Low to High, click to sort ascending $: High to Low $: High to Low, click to sort descending
Open angled view of a yellow catchers mitt with tan lacing, an ALL-STAR logo on the palm, and a Pro-Elite logo on the thumb.
All Star Pro Elite Japan 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: CM3000J1YELBR $499.95
Open view of a teal and floral baseball glove with hot pink lacing and A2000 and Wilson embossed on the palm.
Wilson A2000 RA56 Randy Arozarena 12.75" Baseball Glove: WBW1026941275 $249.95 - $299.95 Price was: $349.95 Used from $269.95
Front and back view of a tan and black baseball glove with red lacing, an embossed player logo, and a red Wilson W.
Wilson A2K JS22 Juan Soto 12.75" Baseball Glove: WBW1010101275 $219.95 - $319.95 Price was: $449.95
Front and back view of a red baseball glove with black lacing, perforated palm, and Wilson A2K branding.
Wilson A2K Spin Control 1787 11.75" Baseball Glove: WBW1004101175 $289.95 Price was: $449.95
Angled open view of a tan and black baseball catchers mitt with ALL-STAR on palm, black lacing, and PROFILED TOE.
All Star Pro Elite 32" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: CM3000XSBT $449.95
Front and back view of a black baseball catchers mitt with ALL-STAR palm, yellow Pro Elite branding, and contrasting stitching.
All Star Pro Elite 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: CM3000SBK $449.95
Front 3/4 view of a tan baseball glove with HEART OF THE HIDE embossed, Rawlings logo, and white lacing.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide 11.5" Baseball Glove: PRORNP4-2TN $259.95 Price was: $329.99
Front-side view of a black and gray baseball glove with textured surfaces, tan lacing, and a red Wilson logo.
Wilson A2K SuperSkin Spin Control 1786 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW101374115 $289.95 Price was: $449.95
Angled front and back view of a black catchers mitt with tan lacing, white stitching, and a gold All-Star logo.
All Star Pro Elite Japan 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: CM3000J1BKCML $499.95 Used from $449.95
Angled view of black and pink baseball gloves with white lacing, featuring A2K and Wilson logos.
Wilson A2K DW5 12" Baseball Glove: WBW10328912 $289.95 Price was: $449.95 Used from $259.95
Front view of a tan and black baseball glove with light blue laces and red trim, featuring the "A2000", "Wilson", and "PF92" text visible on the palm and thumb.
Wilson A2000 PF92 12.25" Spring Collection Baseball Glove: WBW1027481225 $299.95 Price was: $349.95 Used from $269.95
Front view of a blonde Wilson A2000 first base mitt featuring light blue laces, red accents, and prominent A2000 and Wilson logos.
Wilson A2000 1677 12.5" Spring Collection Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW102753125 $299.95 Price was: $349.95 Used from $269.95
Top-down view of a tan and navy baseball glove with orange stitching and A2000 branding.
Wilson A2000 Jose Altuve 11.5" Summer Collection Baseball Glove: WBW103295115 $319.95 Price was: $329.95 Used from $289.95
Angled view of a tan baseball glove with light blue finger backs, pink lacing, and a Rawlings Heart of the Hide logo.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide 11.5" Baseball Glove: PROR314-32CCB $329.99
Angled front view of a tan and black baseball catchers mitt with an open pocket, All-Star logo, and Pro-Elite branding.
All Star Pro Elite 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: CM3000SBT $449.95 Some of the top catchers in baseball choose the All Star Pro Elite Series and I can see why. Great pocket that "pops" and the Japanese Tanned Steerhide really does break-in quick buts holds its shape and structure in all the right places. - Mac M.
Front and back view of two black catchers mitts with yellow stitching, ALL-STAR on palm, and Pro-Elite on back.
All Star Pro Elite 35" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: CM3000BK $449.95
Angled view of a black and gray baseball glove with gold piping, white lacing, and Wilson A2K branding.
Wilson A2K Spin Control 1775 12.75" Baseball Glove: WBW1004131275 $189.95 - $279.95 Price was: $449.95
Open view of a tan and black baseball catchers mitt with ALL-STAR logo, Pro-Elite branding, and black lacing.
All Star Pro Elite 35" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: CM3000BT $449.95
Angled view of a dark brown baseball glove with gold Rawlings Pro Preferred logo, tan lacing, and Rawlings wrist script.
Rawlings Pro Preferred 11.75" Baseball Glove: RPROS315-2MO $359.95 Price was: $379.99
Top-down view of a tan and black baseball glove with Wilson and 2000 embossed on the palm.
Wilson A2000 Ke'Bryan Hayes 11.75" Baseball Glove: WBW1032961175 $319.95 Price was: $329.95 Used from $289.95
Angled view of a tan baseball glove with black lacing, A2K logo on the palm, and a Wilson W logo on the back.
Wilson A2K 1787 11.75" Baseball Glove: WBW1008911175 $379.95 Price was: $449.95
Angled view of a dark brown and tan baseball catchers mitt with a deep pocket, black lacing, and ALL-STAR branding.
All Star S7 Elite 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: CM5000 $169.95 Price was: $299.95
Front view of a dark grey baseball glove with textured palm, white lacing, A2K logo, and Wilson W logo.
Wilson A2K SuperSkin 1787 Spin Control 11.75" Baseball Glove: WBW1008921175 $279.95 Price was: $449.95 Used from $249.95
Angled view of a tan and black baseball glove with A2K and Wilson logos on the palm, and a black back with a tan W logo.
Wilson A2K Spin Control 1786 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW100409115 $319.95 Price was: $449.95
Load More Products

Put Our Expertise to Work

We know gloves - and we’re here to help you find the perfect fit. Get the right one for your game with these resources:

Sizing Guide

Determine the right size glove for you or your player

Glove Coach

Get just-for-you glove recommendations

Resource Guide

Find helpful information written by our roster of Experts

1-866-321-4568

support@justgloves.com

4.9 Star Rating, Google Customer Reviews

Show Comparison